I've been reading The Slightest Philosophy, by Quee Nelson. It's a fascinating defense of what she calls "naive realism" in philosophy. In other words, she maintains that when you see an apple, you actually see a real apple that is out in the world. Probably this sounds non-controversial to most of you, but it's certainly controversial in philosophy, and she tackles the issue head-on.
Most of the book takes the form of a dialog between a philosophy professor and a student. As philosophy books go, it's really easy to read. What's more it's witty, and I keep finding myself in agreement with the author.
I found out about the book only because the estimable Stephen Hicks gave it a good review.
I was pleased that Nelson had some kind words for Thomas Reid, the Scottish philosopher of common sense. I've long been a big fan. I think his criticisms of Hume had real merit. But hardly anyone seems to have read him, so I never get a chance to talk about him with anybody!
"I saw an apple."
That's what I said.
Could it have been
A mere patch of red?
I tasted the apple,
I bit through its peel.
Could it be true
That it's not really real?
I tossed the apple
In the sky.
Doubt its existence?
Please tell me why.
UPDATE: After I finished reading the book, I published an extended rave review here on The Atlasphere.
No comments:
Post a Comment